Quick setup: Set your account's default lot selection to Highest Cost First Out (HIFO). At E*TRADE, also keep qualified funds on Actual Cost. Repeat for each account you connect to HarvestEngine.ai.

E*TRADE setting details with Lot selection set to Highest Cost First Out (HIFO) and Qualified funds cost basis methods set to Actual Cost.
Detail crops of the two E*TRADE settings: HIFO for lot selection, Actual Cost for qualified funds.

Set the account default

Why use HIFO?

HIFO puts the highest-cost shares first, helping your broker's sales line up with the loss lots HarvestEngine chose.

E*TRADE

  1. Log in to E*TRADE and open Profile in the upper right.
  2. Choose Account Preferences.
  3. Under Cost basis, choose Edit.
  4. Under Lot selection, select Highest Cost First Out (HIFO).
  5. In the same dialog, leave Qualified funds cost basis methods set to Actual Cost. If it shows Average cost, change it to Actual Cost.
  6. Choose Save.

With Actual Cost, ETFs follow your main Lot selection setting: HIFO.

Back on the summary, check that Lot selection reads Highest Cost First Out (HIFO) and Qualified funds reads Actual Cost. Repeat for each account you connect to HarvestEngine.ai.

Saved E*TRADE Cost basis summary showing Lot selection as Highest Cost First Out (HIFO) and Qualified funds as Actual Cost.
After saving, check both settings on the summary.

Schwab

  1. Log in to Schwab.com and open your account icon in the upper right.
  2. Choose Account Settings and open the account's cost-basis settings.
  3. Choose High Cost, Schwab's name for selling the highest-cost shares first, and save your selection.

Schwab's cost-basis guide.

Fidelity

  1. Open Fidelity's Change a Cost Basis Tracking Method link and log in.
  2. For your account, under Default Disposal Method, choose Change.
  3. Select Highest Cost, then Save.

Vanguard

  1. Log in to Vanguard. From All accounts, open Portfolio, then Cost basis.
  2. Select the account and choose View/Change cost basis method.
  3. Select the holdings and choose Highest in, first out (HIFO).

Apply HIFO to the holdings you use with HarvestEngine and check the setting when you add a new holding.

Vanguard's account-setting steps and HIFO guide.

Place trades at your broker

Schwab, Fidelity and Vanguard connect read-only: you place any trades there yourself. Check the lot selection on your broker's trade ticket before you submit it.

Keep going

For the differences between methods, read Tax-lot selection methods. For the mechanics, read Tax-loss harvesting basics and Cost basis when your broker changes.