Tax-loss harvesting is a year-round recordkeeping and investment decision, not a December race. A loss on the screen is not yet a deductible loss, and a carried loss is not a savings account from which you choose withdrawals.

Before you get started, we’d recommend reading through Gain-offset planning, Tax alpha: the model and its limitations, Concentrated stock and RSUs, Roth conversions and tax-loss harvesting.

Illustration of a blue timeline with gold markers, calendar arcs, two basket shapes and an open notebook.
Illustrative annual calendar: review records and opportunities throughout the year, without a fixed trading quota or a promise of tax savings.

What does pacing mean?

How should a beginner pace tax-loss harvesting?

Review positions and records throughout the year. Before any loss sale, check recent purchases and planned replacements across relevant accounts. At tax time, apply the annual netting and carryover rules; a larger loss balance is not automatically a better investment result.

There is no universal best month or required number of harvests. Transaction costs, the replacement investment, holding periods and your own circumstances matter. Selling solely to build a loss balance can change an investment you still want to own.

Illustration of a circular blue path beside a container of blue tokens, a gold token and a small gear.
The reservoir is an illustration of recorded losses, not an account with discretionary withdrawals. Annual netting and the allowable deduction determine what remains as a carryover.

A realized loss has an annual order

What if there are no capital gains to offset?

After annual capital-gain netting, a net capital loss may offset ordinary income up to $3,000, or $1,500 for married filing separately. The unused amount may carry forward under the IRS worksheet rules.

The allowable current-year deduction affects the carryover even if you do not claim it. You cannot preserve it for a preferred future year simply by leaving it off your return. The $3,000 limit applies to single and married-filing-jointly returns; the $1,500 limit applies to married filing separately.

LOSS REALIZED GAINS AVAILABLE NOW Enters annual gain/loss netting NO GAINS NOW Deduction, then unused carryover
Losses enter annual capital-gain netting. With no gains, an ordinary-income deduction may still apply; only the unused amount carries forward under the applicable worksheet.

An illustrative calendar, not a trading schedule

What can I review at different points in the year?

Early in the year, reconcile prior returns and carryovers. During the year, monitor acquisitions, realized activity and portfolio changes. Before year-end, review the complete records rather than rushing a sale to meet an arbitrary loss target.

The calendar below is an organizational example. It does not recommend a trade or promise that losses will be available. A December sale can have a January wash-sale purchase within its forward window.

EARLY YEAR Jan – Apr Inventory + Plan Review carryforwards Review planned sales MID YEAR May – Sep Monitor + Adjust Monitor acquisitions Review realized activity LATE YEAR Oct – Dec Clean Up + Net Reconcile gains/losses Avoid year-end rush
Illustrative review calendar: reconcile prior records, monitor acquisitions and realized activity, then reconcile the tax year. This is not a recommended trading schedule.

Investment decisions still come first

Should I sell appreciated investments just to use a carryforward?

Not automatically. A carryforward is one input when considering a sale you otherwise have a reason to make, such as a change in allocation or a cash need. It is not a reason by itself to realize gains.

Annual tax rules determine the application of losses. Your investment choices and tax filing are related, but they are not interchangeable. Harvesting often defers tax rather than eliminating it.

Illustration of an open notebook with blue tokens on one page and a gold arrow, diamond markers and a clock on the other.
A carryover may affect the tax calculation for an investment sale. It does not make a sale suitable or let the taxpayer freely choose the year losses are applied.

The common mistake: incomplete records

What should I avoid when tracking a loss balance?

Do not mistake a running total of harvested losses for the carryover on your filed return. Gains, deductions, wash-sale adjustments and the short-term or long-term character of losses affect the amount carried to the next year.

Keep broker records and your tax return together. Reconcile the next year’s opening balance to the applicable carryover worksheet, including income-related adjustments. The figures below illustrate recordkeeping, not elective use of a reserve.

VS INCOMPLETE RECORDS records missing records running total is not a filed carryover ANNUAL RECONCILIATION losses gain offset apply annual rules records reconciled
Compare incomplete records with annual reconciliation. Neither the size of a loss balance nor a planned gain realization establishes that the after-tax result will be better.

A useful review checklist

What belongs in a year-round review?

Review realized gains and losses, the filed carryover, purchases in the wash-sale window, planned replacements and missing account information. Review purchases before selling, not only after a loss has been realized.

Dividend reinvestments and purchases in a spouse’s account or your own IRA can matter. A product can only work with the accounts and information available to it; unconnected accounts still need a separate review.

REALIZED THIS YEAR What has already been captured this tax year CARRYOVER ON RETURN Reconcile the filed carryover OFFSETTABLE GAINS Netted under annual rules WASH-SALE WINDOWS Timing and replacement windows still open
Keep realized activity, the filed carryover, gain records and wash-sale purchases together. A product estimate does not replace the tax return or cover unconnected accounts.

Continue learning

What should I read next?

Start with the mechanics of harvesting, then learn the carryforward and wash-sale rules before considering a tax-motivated sale.

A repeatable review is useful; a promise of a particular tax benefit is not. This article describes a process, not a performance outcome.

Sources and further reading

Where can I check these rules?

Use the applicable IRS guidance and your tax-return instructions.

Primary sources checked October 11, 2026: IRS Publication 550 (2025), capital losses and wash sales; IRS Topic 409; Revenue Ruling 2008-5 (own IRA/Roth IRA case). These sources address different rules, not one blanket household ruling.

Explore paper practice (invitation required) — join the paper waitlist